5.6单元 — 农业中的可持续性挑战

荒漠化、日渐枯竭的含水层,以及转基因作物的争论——本单元所讲的各种农业体系如何与环境极限相碰撞,以及这一切对考试意味着什么。

17 分钟Unit 5AP® Human Geography
ENKOESVNCN

第5单元的这最后一课,汇集了迄今为止所涵盖的每一种形式的农业——从轮垦地块,到冯·杜能的环带,到绿色革命的谷物带,再到农业综合企业的供应链——最终都会碰到的环境压力点。三项挑战主导着当前的地理学和政策讨论:荒漠化、淡水枯竭,以及转基因作物这一存在争议的角色。结尾的一段简短综合把整个单元串联在一起。

荒漠化

荒漠化是指有生产力的旱地——一种天然半干旱、但历史上能够支持作物种植或放牧的土地——退化为植被稀少、农业价值极低的类似荒漠状态的过程,这一过程通常是人类土地利用压力与气候压力共同作用的结果,而不是单一原因造成的。受到最密切关注的例子是萨赫勒地区,这条半干旱地带紧邻撒哈拉沙漠以南,自东向西横贯非洲,涵盖塞内加尔、马里、尼日尔、乍得和苏丹等国的部分地区。造成这一问题的压力包括牲畜群的过度放牧,超出了当地植被能够再生的能力;为获取薪柴和扩大农田而进行的森林砍伐,而这一地区本就树木覆盖率不足;以及近几十年气候变化带来的降雨变率,使降雨既更难预测,在许多年份也比历史平均水平更为稀少。这些后果相互叠加:随着植被覆盖变薄,裸露的土壤失水速度更快,在风力和该地区偶尔发生的强降雨中也更容易被侵蚀,这进一步降低了这片土地支撑社区所依赖的作物种植和放牧的能力,反过来又促使牧民和农民对仍具生产力的土地施加更大的压力。国际社会对这一问题的认识,催生了1994年开放签署的《联合国防治荒漠化公约》,这是与同一时期的气候变化公约和生物多样性公约并列的三大联合国环境公约之一——这标志着国际社会已开始把旱地退化视为一场独立的全球危机、而不仅仅是一个纯粹的地方性农业问题来认真对待。

用水与含水层枯竭

就全球范围而言,农业遥遥领先地是人类淡水使用量最大的用途,占全球淡水取用量的大约百分之七十,其主要驱动因素是灌溉。整个二十世纪,灌溉规模大幅扩张,这既是绿色革命(第5.3课)需水量大的高产作物品种的直接要求,也是商业农业总体集约化的结果。这些灌溉用水中有很大一部分并非取自河流或降雨,而是取自地下含水层——一种历经数千年甚至数百万年积累而成的含水岩层或沉积层,即使能够得到补给,速度也远远慢于农民从中抽取的速度。

奥加拉拉含水层横跨美国从南达科他州一直到得克萨斯狭长地带的八个州的部分地区,是最清晰的国内案例研究,也是考试中经常被引用的一个参照点。它供应着美国全部灌溉地下水的大约三分之一,数十年的中心支轴灌溉(即在第5.5课中提到的、公共土地测量制度网格内可见的那些圆形田地)已经在其覆盖范围的大片区域内,把它的地下水位可测量地拉低了,在一些地区,自二十世纪中期大规模抽水开始以来,水位已下降了数十英尺。由于这个半干旱地区的自然补给速度极为缓慢,水文学家通常把奥加拉拉含水层的取用描述为在功能上开采一种基本不可再生的资源,而不是可持续地利用一种可再生的资源——这一区分,直接关系到本单元前面所讨论的大平原谷物和养牛经济的长期可行性。类似的含水层压力在全球范围内出现,包括在印度的旁遮普邦,同样使小麦产量增长两倍的绿色革命集约化,也使地下水的开采速度远远超过了自然补给速度。

转基因生物(GMO)

转基因作物自1990年代开始商业化引入,是绿色革命逻辑通过直接基因工程、而非选择性育种手段的一种延伸,至今仍是农业中在地理和政治上争议最大的技术之一。支持者指出了一些具体的收益:经过改造能自行产生抗虫蛋白的Bt玉米和棉花,在采用它们的地区可测量地减少了杀虫剂的使用;耐除草剂的大豆品种简化了杂草控制,并支持了减耕作农法,进而减少了土壤侵蚀;而经过改造能产生β-胡萝卜素(一种维生素A前体)的"黄金大米",是专门为解决维生素A缺乏症而开发的,这是发展中国家部分地区儿童可预防性失明的主要原因之一,不过它在若干目标国家的实际推广多年来一直因监管和公众接受度方面的障碍而放缓。

批评者提出了一系列不同的担忧,其中若干个带有明显的地理维度。转基因种子品种的专利控制,集中在第5.4课所讨论的少数几家农业综合企业公司手中,引发了关于农民保留并再次种植自己收获种子这一传统权利的真实法律冲突——加拿大农民珀西·施迈泽的案例,在1990年代末因专利油菜未经他购买就出现在他的土地上而被起诉,至今仍是种子专利执法与旧有耕作习俗之间张力的一个被广泛引用的例子。对转基因作物的监管接受度也因地区而异,差异显著:美国和美洲大部分地区广泛允许种植转基因作物,而欧盟则维持着严格得多的审批和标签规则,这种分歧本身就说明了一项单一的农业技术,可能出于本质上属于政治和文化、而非技术原因,在其他方面相似的经济体之间不均衡地扩散。

迈向可持续实践

一些做法,有的历史悠久,有的是新近改进的,旨在缓解这些压力,同时不放弃自第一次农业革命以来农业所积累的产量增益。轮作和覆盖作物恢复土壤氮元素和土壤结构,方式与查尔斯·汤森两个半世纪前的四田轮作制大致相同。免耕农业把作物残茬留在田里,避免在两次种植之间翻动土壤,从而减少侵蚀、保持土壤水分。精准农业利用GPS引导的设备,以及逐田块的土壤和水分数据,只在一块田地实际需要的时间和地点施用水、化肥和农药,与旧有的统一施用方法相比,既降低了成本,也减少了径流。农业生态学和有机农业方法尝试用生物性的病虫害和肥力管理——有益昆虫、堆肥、作物多样性——来替代绿色革命的部分化学投入,通常是以牺牲一部分产量来换取更低的投入成本和更小的环境影响。

第5单元综合:为什么这对考试很重要

第5单元贯穿着一条连续的论证线索:农业大约在一万年前在世界若干个地区各自独立地开始(5.1课),一旦市场城市出现,便围绕距离和运输成本被重新组织起来(冯·杜能,5.2课),此后又经历了两次剧烈的集约化——先是英国十八世纪的机械化,后是绿色革命的高产种子技术包(5.1课和5.3课)——接着又围绕企业整合、而非距离被重新组织了一次(5.4课),在农村土地的物理形状上留下了自己永久的指纹(5.5课),如今则正面临着它所依赖的水、土壤和生物多样性的环境极限(本课)。一道贯穿本单元的简答题可能会要求你恰恰追溯这条脉络,或者要求你论证某项具体技术——绿色革命、转基因作物,或精准农业——究竟代表着一个真正的长期解决方案,还是仅仅是一个推迟同一个根本性可持续问题的短期权宜之计。适用于这类题目的一个综合性范例句是:"从诺福克郡的四田轮作,到绿色革命的矮秆谷物,再到今天的转基因作物,每一波农业集约化浪潮,都成功地提高了每英亩的产量,但每一波也都加深了农业对投入品——化石燃料化肥、地下水和专利种子技术——的依赖,而这些投入品本身在地理分布上并不均衡,就水而言,在任何人类可感知的时间尺度上也都是不可再生的。"

练习:自由回答题(FRQ)

本单元的真实AP格式题目,每题均附完整模范答案及真实College Board阅卷人会给出的确切分数。点击题目即可查看答案——不是AI评分,而是按真实考试的评分方式。

LEQ

回答以下题目。

回答以下题目。你的答案必须涵盖(a)至(g)全部七个部分。

世界各地的农业体系源自一组共同的起源,并持续扩散、演变,塑造着农村景观。

(a) 定义自给农业。

(b) 指出第一次农业革命的一个源地(起源地区),并说出该源地驯化的一种植物或动物。

(c) 描述轮垦(刀耕火种农业)作为一种自给农业形式的一项特征。

(d) 描述游牧作为一种自给农业形式的一项特征。

(e) 解释在一项农业创新的传播过程中,迁移扩散与扩展扩散有何不同,并各举一个例子。

(f) 解释第二次农业革命提高欧洲农业生产率的一种方式。

(g) 解释农村聚落格局(例如,分散型与集聚型聚落)如何反映一个地区所实行的农业体系。

模范答案和评分标准以英文呈现——与真实考试一致。
Model answer

(a) Subsistence agriculture is farming carried out primarily to feed the farmer's own household or local community, with little or no surplus produced for sale in a market.

(b) One accepted hearth of the First Agricultural Revolution is the Fertile Crescent in Southwest Asia (the region including parts of modern Iraq, Syria, and Turkey), where wheat and barley were domesticated (other accepted hearths: Mesoamerica — maize/beans/squash; the Andes — potatoes/quinoa; East Asia — rice/millet; Sub-Saharan Africa — sorghum/yams).

(c) Shifting cultivation involves clearing a plot of land, often by cutting and burning vegetation, farming it for a few growing seasons until soil fertility declines, then abandoning the plot to let it lie fallow and regenerate while the farmer clears a new plot elsewhere. It is typically practiced in tropical rainforest environments and supports only low population densities.

(d) Pastoral nomadism involves herding domesticated livestock (such as cattle, sheep, goats, or camels) over seasonal, non-fixed routes in search of pasture and water, rather than cultivating crops on fixed plots of land. It is typically practiced in arid, semi-arid, or high-altitude environments unsuitable for crop farming.

(e) Relocation diffusion occurs when people who carry a practice physically migrate from one location to another, taking the practice with them and establishing it in the new location while it may cease to spread from the origin — for example, European colonists carrying wheat cultivation techniques to the Americas as they settled there. Expansion diffusion occurs when a practice spreads outward from its origin through contact between people, without the originators relocating, and the practice keeps expanding within the source region as well — for example, contour plowing techniques spreading farmer-to-farmer across a agricultural region as neighboring farmers observe and adopt the method.

(f) The Second Agricultural Revolution, associated with the Industrial Revolution, increased productivity through innovations such as mechanized farm equipment (e.g., the seed drill and, later, mechanized reapers and tractors), improved crop rotation systems, and selective breeding of livestock and crops, which increased yields per unit of land and reduced the labor required per farm worker.

(g) Rural settlement patterns reflect the agricultural system practiced: for example, a dispersed (scattered) settlement pattern is common in areas of extensive commercial agriculture (such as U.S. Midwest grain farming) where large individual landholdings require farmhouses to be spaced far apart, while a clustered settlement pattern is common in areas of intensive subsistence rice farming (such as parts of Southeast or South Asia) where farmers live together in a central village and walk out daily to small, nearby fields, allowing shared labor and efficient use of limited arable land.

Scoring · 7 points
1. Correctly defines subsistence agriculture as farming to feed the household/local community with little or no surplus for sale.
2. Identifies a valid hearth of the First Agricultural Revolution and names a plant or animal domesticated there.
3. Describes a valid characteristic of shifting cultivation (e.g., clear/burn/fallow cycle, tropical environment, low population density supported).
4. Describes a valid characteristic of pastoral nomadism (e.g., seasonal herd movement, arid/semi-arid environment, no fixed crop land).
5. Explains the distinction between relocation and expansion diffusion with one valid example of each.
6. Explains a valid mechanism by which the Second Agricultural Revolution raised productivity (mechanization, crop rotation, or selective breeding).
7. Explains how a specific rural settlement pattern (dispersed or clustered) connects logically to a specific agricultural system, with a supporting example or reasoning.
LEQ

利用下面的数据表回答以下题目。

利用下面的数据表回答以下题目。你的答案必须涵盖(a)至(g)全部七个部分。

材料来源:环绕集镇梅多布鲁克的农田的假设性土地利用和地租数据

距梅多布鲁克镇中心的距离 | 每公顷平均地租 | 主导土地利用 0—5公里 | 420美元 | 乳业和商品菜园(水果和蔬菜) 5—15公里 | 310美元 | 用于薪柴和木材的森林 15—40公里 | 150美元 | 谷物农业(小麦) 40—100公里 | 60美元 | 养牛业和牲畜放牧

(a) 指出提出了最能解释表中所示格局的农村土地利用模型的农业地理学家。

(b) 定义该模型中所使用的"竞租"概念。

(c) 描述为什么距梅多布鲁克更近的土地,每公顷地租高于距离更远的土地。

(d) 描述为什么乳业和商品菜园位于最靠近镇中心的环带,而不是最外层的环带。

(e) 参照运输成本,解释在这一模型的最初版本中,为什么用于薪柴和木材的森林比谷物农业更靠近镇中心。

(f) 解释把这一模型应用于当今美国农业土地利用的一项局限性。

(g) 利用数据表,解释冷藏卡车运输的广泛引入,可能会如何改变乳制品与镇中心距离和地租之间的关系。

模范答案和评分标准以英文呈现——与真实考试一致。
Model answer

(a) The model shown is von Thünen's model of agricultural land use, developed by Johann Heinrich von Thünen.

(b) Bid-rent refers to the rent a farmer is willing and able to pay for a parcel of land, which reflects the value of the land for a given agricultural use; bid-rent decreases as distance from the central market increases because transportation costs to move goods to market rise with distance, reducing the profit available to pay as rent.

(c) Land closer to Meadowbrook commands higher rent because transportation costs to move goods to the central market are lower for nearby land, leaving farmers more profit to bid for that land; competition among farmers who want to minimize transport costs and time (especially for perishable goods) also drives up rent for the closest parcels.

(d) Dairying and market gardening are located nearest the town because they produce perishable goods (milk, fresh produce) that must reach market quickly before spoiling and are also costly to transport per unit of value, so farmers of these goods can afford, and need, to outbid other land uses for the most accessible land.

(e) In von Thünen's original model, wood was a bulky, heavy commodity that was expensive and difficult to transport over land before mechanized transportation existed, and it was in constant demand in town for fuel and building material, so it needed to be located close enough to the market to keep transport costs manageable — closer than lower-value, less bulky grain, which could be transported profitably over greater distances.

(f) One valid limitation: von Thünen's model assumes an isotropic plain (uniform, featureless terrain, transportation cost equal in all directions, a single central market, and no external trade), conditions that do not hold in the present-day United States, which has variable terrain, multiple transportation modes and networks (highways, rail) that create transport corridors rather than uniform rings, multiple competing markets, and global trade that allows perishable or bulky goods to be shipped long distances profitably using modern refrigeration and rapid transport.

(g) Refrigerated trucking would reduce the spoilage risk and effective transportation cost of moving dairy products long distances, weakening the locational advantage that land near Meadowbrook currently holds for dairying; as a result, dairy production could shift farther from the town center where land rent is lower, and the steep rent gradient favoring the innermost ring for dairying and market gardening would likely flatten, since farmers producing perishables would no longer need to be located immediately adjacent to the market to remain profitable.

Scoring · 7 points
1. Correctly identifies von Thünen as the geographer associated with this land-use model.
2. Correctly defines bid-rent as the rent a land use can support, which reflects value net of transportation cost to market.
3. Describes the inverse relationship between distance from the market and rent, tied to rising transportation costs.
4. Describes why perishable/high-transport-cost goods (dairying, market gardening) locate nearest the market.
5. Explains the historical transportation-cost reasoning for placing forest/timber closer to town than grain in the original model.
6. Explains a valid limitation of applying the model to the modern U.S. (e.g., non-isotropic terrain, transport networks/corridors, multiple markets, modern refrigerated/global trade).
7. Explains, using the data, how refrigerated trucking would plausibly flatten or shift the rent-distance gradient for dairy products.
LEQ

利用下面的两份材料回答以下题目。

利用下面的两份材料回答以下题目。你的答案必须涵盖(a)至(g)全部七个部分。

材料1:假设的南亚小麦和水稻平均产量,1965—1985年

年份 | 小麦平均产量(每公顷千克) | 水稻平均产量(每公顷千克) 1965年 | 850 | 1,100 1975年 | 1,600 | 1,700 1985年 | 2,300 | 2,450

材料2:一个小农合作社的发言,2020年 "自从这家大型农业综合企业开始与本地种植者签约以来,大多数农民只种植合同项下供应的单一杂交种子品种,把全部收成专门卖给该公司的加工厂,而且不再保留自己收成的种子留待来年再种。"

(a) 定义绿色革命。

(b) 利用材料1,描述1965年至1985年间小麦和水稻产量的总体趋势。

(c) 指出两项与绿色革命相关、有助于解释材料1中所示产量趋势的农业投入品。

(d) 利用材料2,描述该合作社发言所体现的农业综合企业的一项特征。

(e) 解释材料2中所描述的小农,因与单一农业综合企业签订合同农业协议而面临的一项经济风险。

(f) 解释与产生材料1中所示产量增长的绿色革命做法相关的一项环境可持续性担忧。

(g) 解释材料2中所描述的农业综合企业垂直整合,如何既有利于、又威胁到了农村农业社区。

模范答案和评分标准以英文呈现——与真实考试一致。
Model answer

(a) The Green Revolution (also called the Third Agricultural Revolution) refers to the period beginning in the mid-twentieth century in which the development and spread of high-yield hybrid seed varieties, synthetic fertilizers, irrigation, and mechanization dramatically increased agricultural output, especially of grain crops such as wheat and rice, in many developing countries.

(b) Source 1 shows that both wheat and rice yields per hectare increased substantially and consistently from 1965 to 1985 — wheat yields roughly tripled (from 850 to 2,300 kg/hectare) and rice yields more than doubled (from 1,100 to 2,450 kg/hectare) over the twenty-year period.

(c) Two valid inputs: high-yield variety (HYV) hybrid seeds (developed through selective breeding to produce more grain per plant) and synthetic chemical fertilizers (which supply nutrients that allow the HYV seeds to reach their higher yield potential). Other acceptable inputs: expanded irrigation and mechanized equipment (tractors, mechanized harvesting).

(d) Source 2 illustrates vertical integration / contract farming, a characteristic of agribusiness in which a single large firm controls or coordinates multiple stages of the agricultural supply chain — in this case supplying the seed input, and also purchasing and processing the entire output — so that independent farmers effectively grow a single standardized crop for one buyer rather than making independent planting and marketing decisions.

(e) One valid risk: because the farmers sell exclusively to one firm and plant only the variety it supplies, they have no alternative buyer and little bargaining power over the price they receive, leaving them economically vulnerable if the firm lowers the price it pays, changes contract terms, or ends the contract; because they no longer save their own seed, they must also purchase new seed from the company each season, increasing their costs and dependency.

(f) One valid concern: intensive Green Revolution farming relying on heavy irrigation and synthetic fertilizer/pesticide application can degrade soil quality over time, deplete or contaminate groundwater and surface water supplies through runoff, and encourage monocropping of a narrow set of HYV seeds, which reduces agricultural biodiversity and can increase vulnerability to pests or disease that affect a single genetically similar crop.

(g) Vertical integration by agribusiness firms has benefited rural farming communities by providing farmers with guaranteed access to improved seed inputs, a reliable buyer for their harvest, and often technical support, which can raise and stabilize household income compared to selling on an open, price-volatile market. At the same time, it has threatened these communities by concentrating economic power and decision-making in a single outside firm, eroding farmers' independence (loss of seed-saving and choice of what to grow), and making the community's livelihood dependent on the continued presence and pricing decisions of one company, with little recourse if the firm withdraws or changes terms.

Scoring · 7 points
1. Correctly defines the Green Revolution as the mid-twentieth-century expansion of high-yield seeds, fertilizer, irrigation, and mechanization that raised agricultural output.
2. Describes the upward yield trend in Source 1 for both wheat and rice from 1965 to 1985 (with reference to the data).
3. Identifies two valid Green Revolution inputs (e.g., HYV seeds, synthetic fertilizer, irrigation, mechanization) linked to the yield trend.
4. Describes vertical integration/contract farming as the agribusiness characteristic shown in Source 2.
5. Explains a valid economic risk to smallholder farmers from single-buyer contract dependency (e.g., loss of bargaining power, seed-purchase cost, no alternative buyer).
6. Explains a valid environmental sustainability concern tied to Green-Revolution-style intensive farming (soil degradation, water depletion/contamination, or reduced biodiversity from monocropping).
7. Explains both a benefit and a threat that vertical integration poses to rural farming communities, connected to Source 2.